Wednesday, August 24, 2011

4-0 to the Engerland.........

So what was mooted as a close contest turned into a one sided whitewash as England enjoyed their coronation as the World's No1 Test team in both glorious and ruthless style. For India there is almost nothing that can be taken from the series and the most worrying question for all Test Cricket lovers is do the Indian Cricket Board and many of the team actually care?

On many levels it is hard for English cricket fans to comprehend their team currently sitting at the pinnacle of the sport, such has been the generation length periods of mediocrity with only flashes of previous success. It is also hard to ascertain just how good this team actually might be given the penchant for playing everything down, for talking about the opposition being tired and injured, of the conditions being in England's favour, the list goes on.

What is for sure is that if it had been McGrath, Gillespie and Warne ripping through the India batting line up and Hayden, Ponting, Waugh and Martyn smashing the ball to all parts the talk would have been of what great players they are, the best in the World end of story. Substitute Anderson, Broad, Swann, Cook, Trott, Pietersen and Bell and the talk circles to almost finding excuses for their excelling. Gilchrist was often talked of as a game changer yet Matt Prior is doing the exactly the same at no7 for this England team as well as enjoying fantastic glove work.

In the likes of especially McGrath, Warne and Gilchrist we are of course talking about the all time greats and about players who did it over a vast amount of years. The point is not to suggest that the England players are necessarily at that level yet but that they are deserving of the plaudits and actually are as good as their statistics and rankings suggest - and that no one should be apologising for it.

One commentator suggested that so many runs are scored nowadays because of the lack of good bowling, there is no Ambrose, Walsh, Donald, Pollock, McGrath, Gillespie, Warne, Akram, Waqar, the list goes on but as oft is the case there is always romanticising of the past. It is true that the West Indies in particular have gone in to a steep decline but with the likes of the bowling talent in the current England team, Zaheer Khan, Harbajhan, Malinga, Vettori, the only just retired Murali and the outstanding South African pair of Steyn and Morkel there is still considerable world class bowling talent out there.

England however are not the finished article and the batting lineup is at the least one short. Eoin Morgans' technique looks suspect against high class seam bowling which at test level he will come up against especially against South Africa. Bopara also is simply not good enough and England must find some further young batting talent in the middle order as well as finding an option at opener to keep the pressure on Strauss in particular to score runs. The South African attack will not be so forgiving should the likes of Trott get injured again.

The seam attack options are superlative with Tremlett and Finn waiting in the wings but a genuine back up to Swann needs to be found now that Monty's star has seemingly fallen and given that his fielding is simply not up to modern day standards.

England, the likes of Flintoff and Harmison having moved on will this time hopefully not fall in to the trap of 2005, writing books and accepting medals and all thinking 'we've done it'. Andy Flower and Andrew Strauss must drive home the message that this is only the beginning and the success can be built on and they surely will.

For India, this has been a debacle from start to finish. Their calendar ensured they showed up late with little time for practise. With the exception of the truly remarkable Rahul Dravid, their batting line up was undercooked for the entire series. Their bowlers, shorn of their spearhead in Zaheer and their best spin option in Harbajhan offered little in the way of hope as their inability to bowl England out even once in an innings never mind twice showed so painfully.

When World No1s in any sport are beaten, it is usually by a fractional margin and certainly not to the degree of it not being a contest, that being the case there has to be another factor at work.

India will indeed point to fatigue and injuries but the reality is that it is India's unquenchable thirst for cricket on its' own shores that is causing these problems. The introduction of the IPL has been a wonderful one but with both it and the Champions League in the International calendar, there is simply no time for their players to rest.

The other issue at hand for India is that by playing so many T20 and OD Internationals, the skill set required for playing test cricket is gradually eroded and it was clear to see for all during this series. The likes of VVS and MS Dhoni continually got out playing shots with an open face. They were limited overs shots, not for a test field with a slip cordon. Sreesanth and Sharma bowled decent spells but couldn't replicate it two or three times in an innings as is required in a Test Match.

The talent of this current India team is without question and indeed their batting lineup contains some all time greats and possibly the all time great. The question is whether Test Cricket has a long term future in India and whether the Indian Cricket Board wishes to put the time, effort and most importantly emphasis on the longer format of the game or simply follow the quicker and far richer short formats.

Accordingly, India will give England a far greater fight in the OD Internationals and one T20 that will follow, indeed they may well win most of them. After all India have only just recently won the World Cup in such magnificent fashion and are the best one day team in the World, the question is whether it is all coming at the expense of the long term future of Test Cricket - No Nonsense.

3 comments:

  1. All credit to England for winning the series in style and climbing to the Peak. Although, the series saw many match winning and stupendous performances by multiple players from English side, my Series Winner was Stuart Broad. He was just marvelous with both ball and bat. India may have lost the series by an awful margin but their tired feet didn't start as bad as it appeared in the end. They won two crucial tosses in the opening two games and England were in trouble at Trent Bridge both when they were batting (124/8) and while bowling (267/4), but each time Stuart Broad came in for the rescue. India could have and should have won the match (levelling the series) but for the heroics of one of the best all rounders in the game today. That was the turning point! After the defeat at Trent Bridge , India lost it psychologically. What happened afterwards is history. Dravid proved yet again that there was no daemon in the Pitch and that it's all about application in difficult situations. I hope we again see him play in England and regain the lost glory for India.

    Having been handed over The Mace, this English side has proven itself. However, as competitive was to reach the top over the years, equally competitive will be to stay on there. A true no.1 wins all around the world and excels in all conditions. India did it for 2 years but could not do that this time and payed the price. England will also have to measure up to the expectations that everyone will have from them now.

    We await the Test Cricket World Cup format to be finalized and implemented. Hopefully it is done soon because in the commercialized cricket world of today, it is the only hope for Test cricket.
    I think all formats of cricket need different skill sets and thus are equally challenging and important.

    All eyes on the ODI series now. I think England has the advantage (moral as well as on the fitness front) over India after the thumping victory in the Test series. India will have to put in extra-ordinary efforts and show extra-ordinary character to do well in ODIs.

    May The Better Team Win!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Good blog Duff. England hunt as a pack. With the exception of Strauss, all the batsmen have scored big. Cook, Trott, Bell and KP look as strong as any batting line up in the world and who would I have instead ? None of the Indians bar Dravid. Any Aussies ? No, not really. Ponting is on the slide (although he will still put many more runs on the board yet, unless Aus really struggle and he gets bored) Kallis and Jayawardene maybe from the others.

    All the bowlers have taken big wickets when needed and when the chips have been down, someone has put their hand up and turned it round for England - Prior, Broad, Pietersen in particular have brought England out of real pressure situations this summer.

    Prior does indeed look top notch. As much as it pains me to say it. You know I am a big James Foster fan - he should have played so many more tests for England.
    Prospects look ok. England do need a number 6 or they push Prior up and pick another spinner. Not so sure Monty is on the slide, isn't he the top wicket taker in Div 1 of the Championship ? He will surely go on tour. I can't think of any others to challenge him. Borthwick maybe, Rashid prob not. Patel hope not.

    Batting-wise you can pick from a list off the top of my head : Taylor, Hales, Bairstow, Stokes, Maynard, Carberry and Hildreth.

    Bowlers : Finn, Tremlett, Onions, Woakes, Meaker

    4 batsmen and 4 bowlers in the respective ranking top 10s - heady times.

    The real interesting and encouraging thing I see is that Eng will not suffer from the same problem as the Aussies. McGrath, Warne, Hayden, Langer, Martyn, Gilchrist and Gillespie all left the side within 12-18 months of each other. The only player creeping that way is Strauss. The others are at (KP, Trott, Jimmy, Prior) or approaching (Cook, Broad, Bell) their peak.

    Tip top.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Chadders is Gay. No doubt about it

    ReplyDelete